Matthew Joyce is widely known as a hard working and dedicated family man with a successful career in the property industry.  This web site was created and was independently maintained to provide accurate information regarding two court cases that Matt Joyce comprehensively won and emphatically cleared his name.  It is an interactive medium so please feel free to forward comments for inclusion. 

The site also contains weblinks to recent news articles, comments from friends and colleagues and attachments to relevant information.

Matt was detained in Dubai in January 2009 and released in October 2009 based on false and fabricated evidence which resulted in two court cases. The Australian proceeding concluded on June 8, 2012 when the Supreme Court of Victoria ruled that the case against Matthew ‘failed in all respects’. The judgment cites that evidence of bribery allegations by the prosecution’s witnesses were ‘utterly unreliable, increasingly nonsensical’ and ‘the witnesses (Abedian and Brown) cannot be taken as reliable witnesses of truth’. The court established that there was an “invention” by Abedian and Brown (Sunland) of a story, which “falsely implicated Matt Joyce in a non-existent fraud”.  The court added that the case also failed because no fraudulent intent or knowledge ever existed.

The judge also ordered Sunland to withdraw their civil claim against Matthew in Dubai as it was found to be an “abuse of process and completely vexatious and oppressive”.

Elements of the claims against Matt were judged as “a complete fabrication”. Matt has therefore been cleared of any wrongdoing and the case against him has been dismissed. See a full transcript of the judgment here.  

Further, on the 14th September 2012 the Supreme Court also found that Sunland proceeded with the action in order to gain advantage and to influence the Dubai Prosecutor. The court condemned "Sunland's willingness to implicate Joyce 'unjustifiably'" and ordered indemnity costs against Sunland. The judgment states “"Sunland commenced and continued the present proceeding in willful disregard of known facts and law and also for an ulterior purpose". See a full transcript of the indemnity costs judgment here.

On the 8th September 2013 the Court of Appeal emphatically upheld the earlier judgement. The Court of Appeal also ruled that aspects of the evidence David Brown gave to the Authorities in Dubai was "fundamentally misleading", that he made a "series of untrue statements", and engaged in "untruthful exaggerations and that his witness statement in Australia was "directly contrary to a number of statements he made to the procecutors in Dubai". The Court of Appeal up held that Soheil Abedian, Sunland's Chairman and David Brown, its COO are "unreliable witnesses of the truth" (legal term for liars).

The Court of Appeal also ruled that Sunland's "proceedings must be presumed to have been commenced and continued for a collateral purpose and ulterior motive", including defending its commercial reputation and protecting the position of David Brown in Dubai.

In addition, during the Appeal hearing, Sunland and it lawyer's Thompsons (of which Sunland Director Ron Eames is a partner) were exposed for making a secret deal with a material witness who is also a defendant in the Dubai matter, and trying to hide the existence of this secret deal from the courts. So serious is this matter of witness tampering by Sunland that it was tabled before Parliament on the 30th May 2013. Sunland also remain under investigation by ASIC, the Australian Securities Investments Commission. A full copy of the appeal judgment is attached here.

On 26th September 2013 the Appeal Court ordered yet further costs against Sunland on an indemnity basis, citing "..........Sunland ought to have known its appeal was hopeless"." Sunland ought to have realised that it would fail at the first hurdle"."Sunland's argument that Justice Croft should have considered evidence of a "serious allegation of a covert payment of money" was "hopeless"." Sunland failed to establish........any of the essential elements necessary to prove its claim. The reasons for this were various but fundamentally Sunland could not make good a case based upon the inconsistent and inadequate evidence of its own witnesses"."........Sunland's appeal againt the costs judgement of the trial judge had no chance of success".

Download judgment transcript - PDF 1 PDF 2

On October 16th 2013 Sunland abandoned any further rights to appeal - the Australian matter is now over. This welcome move followed two scathing rulings against Sunland, judgements which called into question the ulterior motives, intergrity and honesty of its Chairman, Soheil Abedian and COO, David Brown.  A copy of Sunland's notice discontinuance is attached here.

In Dubai the Court of First Instance subpoenaed Soheil Abedian and David Brown three times in order for them to recant the lies and fabrication's they intentionally made to the Dubai Authorities. On each occassion they ignored the subpoena's and failed to appear.

The Dubai trial took 5 years. The Court of First Instances referred the case back to the prosecutor stating that "the facts didn't match the evidence" and with no adverse findings. The prosecutor then re-filed the same charges in a different court. Then on the 10th November 2013, three judges, including Dubai's Chief Justice aquitted Matt Joyce of all charges with similar findings to the Victorian Supreme Court." The judgement states the case " lacked any genuine evidence" and that the court did "not accept as credible the testimony of David Brown" and that the " prosecution built its case on the sole evidence of David Brown, which the court was unable to accept because it contained contradictions, and is contrary to the facts and investigations." The Dubai Court was emphatic in ruling that Joyce's employer had also not been defrauded and that it sufferred no damage or loss and that Joyce did NOT personally benefit or profit from the transaction.  The Dubai matter is now also over.  Both the Arabic and English translation of the judgement is attached here.

On 20th September 2012 is was revealed before the Australian Parliament that Soheil Abedian was part of an Australian corruption investigation when he was called before the Queensland Crime and Corruption Commission in 2006 for the accusation of bribing public officials. Refer attached report.

Matt has now returned to Australia and is reunited with his family.

At the time friends and colleagues of Matt's launched an e-petition to support an appeal to the Australian government to actively pursue the immediate release of Matt with utmost vigour. A copy of that e-petition can be found at http://www.bringmatthome.com/.

 

Audio

ABC Radio National Background Briefing, by Wendy Carlisle on 774 ABC Radio - October 13, 2013
Listen now:

ABC Radio National - February 28, 2013
Government not helping families stuck in Dubai
Listen now:

ABC Radio National Breakfast - February 27, 2013
AUSTRALIANS UNDER HOUSE ARREST IN DUBAI
Listen now:

ABC Radio National PM - July 23, 2012
Listen now:

Jack Rush QC, interviewed by Jon Faine on 774 ABC Radio - June 12, 2012
Listen now:

related links

 

feature contributions

Brendan Crotty

Former Managing Director of Australand

Posted 31st Oct 2009...more »

Peter Dransfield

Company Director and Property Consultant
Former Multiplex non Executive Director

Posted 31st Oct 2009...more »

Karl Fender

Director of Fender Katsalidis Mirams Architects
Former President of the Australian Institute of Architects, Victorian Chapter, National President Elect

Posted 31st Oct 2009...more » 

Sean O'Toole

Managing Director and Chief Executive of Landcom

Posted 15th Nov 2009...more »

Robert (Bas) Seymour and Jonathan (Jo) Breadmore

Former Grazier and Former Chairman of Geelong Grammar School Council

Posted 12th Jan 2010...more »

Cullen Gunn

Landscape Architect

Posted 12th Jan 2010...more »

Wendy Jamieson

Posted 24 Jan 2010...more »

Shaun Wildey

Posted 12 Dec 2011...more »

Yu Hon Nam

Posted 25 Jan 2012...more »

Dale Alcock

Posted 14 June 2012...more »

Matthew Vincent

Posted 18 June 2012...more »

Ross Biancato

Former General Manager Australand

Posted 18 June 2012...more »

David Jamieson

Posted 19 June 2012...more »

 

 

archives

View more testimonials »